@rsirian1
Thanks! I've been looking and I also found this Facebook post that goes into it a bit more.
So, as best I can figure out, it was some kind of gaming token made in the late 19th century/early 20th but I can't find any information about what the game might have been. Maybe just poker or something mundane like that?
There's also this post on CoinTalk that has a bit of insight but is basically asking the same questions.
The closest I can get to a value is from this Bradford's auction which sold for $26 and calls it rare.