Who is right?
Another good question.
First :My comment<We have to know something?> was absolute correct.
Second:The member of the other site has his personally opinion as i have.
A coin certification company can only tell the real truth or an unselfish expert collector that hardly i believe you can find.
Because the coins have high price ,i am of the opinion that give the coins for certification and finally know who is right.
I would be suspicious because of the sharp looking edges in all the pictures,
but weighing them on an accurate scale and comparing to specs usually listed
in the Krause catalog would help to narrow down an opinion one way or the other.