1858 One Cent - Province of Canada, Coinage Orientation

I have an inquiry into the 3 known graded examples listed by Charlton on pg. 40/41 for 1858 coinage orientation.
I read a forum topic from 2013 on coincommunity.com where a poster was stating two of those coins were graded EF-40. (the other one may be a coin authenticated in 2013 by NGC but not graded).

I wrote a query into that topic thread hoping the poster would reply, but did not receive an answer. I emailed Charlton & Krause and they could not provide any info.

Does anyone here have information about the 3 graded types, and where that info might be stored or accessed?

I'm waiting for my 1858 with coinage orientation to be returned from ICCS with a grade assigned.

Many thanks

It would be a wonder if you got a serious reply from Krause...
Could you post pictures?

Цитата: "PetrusAscanus"​It would be a wonder if you got a serious reply from Krause...
​Could you post pictures?

​LOL!
The response from Krause was less than pitiful. Sounded more like an ordinary publishing company than a company interested in coins.

Pictures. I'm mad at myself, I forgot to take pics prior to sending the coin to ICCS. Will post pic when coin is received back.

This is a rare one, and I really want to find out what the other 3 grades are, as grade comparisons would be an excellent source of valuation. Mine would be the 4th known graded example.

https://www.victoriancent.com
Ask Rob as he is the expert and has 1 (I think)

Wow, spoken about an expert. Very interesting slide show.

Цитата: "fourmack"​https://www.victoriancent.com
​Ask Rob as he is the expert and has 1 (I think)

​Thanks, Fourmack, I got a hold of Rob. He says he recalls seeing two that were graded EF,
at auction, but one was corroded and did not sell. He doesn't remember the selling price of the other.

Anyway, I got back the ICCS graded 1858 today. They gave it an F-12, which was a happy surprise!
Here's pics, unfortunately had to take them thru 2 layers of plastic casing.