Help on chinese coinage - Fake? [решено]

Hi everyone,
I need help since I know nothing regarding Chinese coins. So, I’m sorry if at any point I sound stupid, that is because I really am on this subject (Chinese coinage).
So, I got a big lot of coins and I found some Chinese coins in it. I tried hard to identify them, and I found similar coins, just the weight is all wrong for the first 3 coins. My scale is not precise, but the difference is just too much. So, I’m wondering if I identify the wrong ones, or maybe if the coins that I got are counterfeit coins (I think that is the case). But before I throw them in the bin, I decided to ask for help, maybe someone here has a higher expertise on the subject. Also, any help on identifying the last coin will be appreciated.

Here are the pictures, and below I added some information for each coin.



COIN #1
Similar coin on Numista catalogue: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces36541.html
Weight: 4.7 grams
Diameter: 24 mm

COIN #2
Similar coin on Numista catalogue: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces17772.html
Weight: 4.4 grams
Diameter: 23.5 mm

COIN #3
Similar coin on Numista catalogue: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces22820.html
Weight: 4.5 grams
Diameter: 23.5 mm

COIN #4
Similar coin on Numista catalogue: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces26115.html
Weight: 7.4 grams
Diameter: 29 mm

COIN #5
Similar coin on Numista catalogue: ????
Weight: 3.1 grams
Diameter: 22.5 mm

Any information will help.

Thank you.

Best regards,
Lucas Lorenzi.

Hello

The fifth is one of this one
Could be the 22.225

Not an expert but i would say that 1,2,3 coins weights are a bit too far off, however like you said you don't have accurate scales. Note i sceptical of all Chinese currency that is silver as far to often it is fake, even having fake wear.

Definitely fake for silvers. Coin #2 The English inscription does not match with Chinese.,

but big chance that #4 and #5 is genuine.
Coin #4 refers to https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces166805.html


Chris

Цитата: "LCW1991"​Definitely fake for silvers. Coin #2 The English inscription does not match with Chinese.,
​
​but big chance that #4 and #5 is genuine.
​Coin #4 refers to https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces166805.html
​
​
​Chris

Hi Chris,
Thank you so much for the help confirming that the silver coins are fake.
And also to point me in the right direction on coin #4.

Thank you also Gros for helping on coin #5.

One more thing, anyone knows if coin #4 or #5 are valuable? Or just standard coinage made in billions?

Thanks.

Best regards,
Lucas Lorenzi

Hello Lucas

The #5 is a really common Chinese coin no real value in this condition

Regards

Both coins are not valuable and can be commonly found in Asian market for around USD 2 each.

Chris